Peter Trumbore: Observations/Research/Diversions

Subscribe


 

I’ll take a knee

September 26, 2017 By Pete Trumbore

DKoJTRKUIAAfkCH.jpg-large

This “debate” we’re having about NFL players taking a knee during the playing of the national anthem, has nothing to do with the anthem, or loyalty to the flag, or honoring our veterans, or our active-duty military.

It’s about protesting racial injustice, and specifically the rash of killings of unarmed African Americans by police under circumstances that are more than a little dubious.

But what if it were about the anthem, or the flag, or the military? I’d still take a knee, and support the right of anyone else to do likewise. Because, as an American, I’m not loyal to any of those things.

Back in January, when president-elect Donald Trump was said to be imposing personal loyalty tests on those who sought jobs in his administration, and those who were planning to protest Trump’s inauguration were denounced as disloyal to the office of the presidency, I wrote about what I was, and was not, loyal to.

Here’s some of what I had to say back then:

I am loyal to the values that our country claims to stand for, that our presidents vow to uphold, that our symbols – like the flag and the anthem – are intended to represent.

I am not loyal to any of these people, or offices, or things for themselves, but for the ideas they serve and embody.

So if I feel I need to burn a flag, or take a knee during the anthem, or turn my back on a president, or rally against another’s inauguration in order to stand up for the values that make us who we are as a people, then that’s what I’ll do.

I meant what I said in January, and I mean it today, nearly 10 months later. If we’re not loyal to our values and ideals, why be loyal to the symbols we claim they represent?

I am not loyal to the president

January 11, 2017 By Pete Trumbore

me-0913-loyaltyoath1_970

Not to Barack Obama, whom I deeply respect.

I will not be loyal to Donald Trump, for whom I have nothing but scorn.

I cannot even say that I am loyal to the Office of the President. No, when I think about my own political loyalties, they are to no person and to no political office.

I’ve been thinking about this as I sort through my own feelings concerning the transfer of political power we are about to experience. The presidency will be handed from a man of deep integrity and honor who has dedicated his adult life to the service others to a dishonorable, perfidious grifter who has spent his life serving no one and nothing greater than himself.

But I feel no sense of loyalty to Obama. Loyalty to the man, even loyalty to the office, strikes me as dangerous. Loyalty of that sort tempts us to ignore, excuse, or justify conduct that should otherwise be inexcusable and unjustifiable.

While I’m at it I may as well admit that I’m not loyal to the flag either; the pledge of allegiance has always made me uncomfortable. Hell, I don’t even like the national anthem and I hate the sense of coerced patriotism that I feel when it gets played before the start of sporting events and the like.

In earlier decades admissions like this might have landed me in front of some congressional committee. Today they might get me called out on social media by some hyper-conservative higher education “watchdog” on the prowl for evidence of the liberal degeneracy of university faculty, or denounced on the floor of the statehouse by some right-wing legislator looking for an excuse gut spending on public universities and put an out-of-touch ivory-tower academic in his place.

So what am I loyal to?

I’m loyal to the principles that underpin our democracy. I’m loyal to the principles of liberty, virtue, justice, equality, and fairness that animated our founding and that we have spent almost three centuries trying, sometimes haltingly, to perfect.

I am loyal to the values that our country claims to stand for, that our presidents vow to uphold, that our symbols – like the flag and the anthem – are intended to represent.

I am not loyal to any of these people, or offices, or things for themselves, but for the ideas they serve and embody.

So if I feel I need to burn a flag, or take a knee during the anthem, or turn my back on a president, or rally against another’s inauguration in order to stand up for the values that make us who we are as a people, then that’s what I’ll do.

Those are acts of loyalty.

Archives

Categories

Copyright © 2023